hands off, the fringes

Like a million other concerned people, I attended the local Hands Off! protest yesterday. I wasn’t sure how many people would show up, considering it was a cold, blustery day (about 42F with steady 14mph winds and gusts about twice that). I thought we might still get a thousand people. Maybe.

The local news estimated the attendance to be around 7,500, and they tend to be conservative in their estimates. It was an eclectic crowd with a variety of concerns. Climate change, veteran’s benefits, social security, health care, education, trans rights, social justice, the court system, immigrant’s rights, Ukraine, and more. But there was absolutely universal condemnation of Comrade Trump, Elon Musk, and DOGE.

The protest began, as all protests do, with speeches. I confess, I paid little attention to the actual speeches, though I was pleased to hear the crowd cheering and applauding. During the speeches, I left the main crowd and moved around the fringes. Why? Because there are folks who want to protest and make their voices heard BUT for any of a thousand reasons may be uncomfortable with crowds.

The folks on the fringe of the protest were pretty much the same people who made up the rest of the crowd. They were mostly white (this IS Iowa, after all) but beyond that they seemed to be a fairly representative sample of the protesters. There were young kids (some in strollers), and working class folks, and church-goers, and goths, and office workers, and trans folk, and wine moms, and college students, and old folks (some using walkers), and union members, and passers-by who just wanted to know what the hell was going on.

One of the things I found most interesting about the event was that everybody was 1) happy and 2) pissed off. They were pissed off enough to give up their Saturday to carry signs and listen to speeches and shout for Elon Musk to be deported and for Donald Trump to be impeached and to take over one of the main city streets and march a mile or so in cold, blustery weather to the state capitol building, where they listened to still more speeches. But they were also happy and laughing and clearly delighted to be with others who agreed with them. There was a tremendous sense of relief, and a sense of urgency, and a sense of something approaching hope and optimism. That all seems contradictory, but it didn’t feel like it.

Nobody there thought this march–or any of the hundreds of other marches–was going to change anything. Nobody there was that innocent. But it felt like there was a shared commitment to changing the way we govern ourselves. There was a very clear feeling of joy at the chance to express themselves, to carry signs and chant slogans and shout out their frustration and rage and hope.

It was also clear that this was the first time a lot of these people had attended a protest. At the beginning, there was a tentativeness to the crowd. A lot of looking around to see if anybody was watching, if anybody was upset or offended by what they were doing. This was especially clear when the organizers asked them to take to the street and march up to the capitol, where we’d join up with a second protest. We are a car-brained culture, and these people were unsure about the propriety of taking over a street without permission.

But they did it. And when cars approached the head of the march, they had to stop and make a U-turn. At the back of the march, a lone police officer in a squad car followed to insure no drivers disrupted the march from behind. Within a few hundred yards, this crowd of normal Iowans were chanting, “Whose street? OUR STREET!” There was a palpable sense of released anger and resentment and liberation. It really was OUR street.

When the crowd took to the street, these two women with their “We the People” sign led the way. It seemed appropriate. Because it’s true. We, the people, are massively pissed off. And yesterday, we let those malignant fuckwits of the Trump administration know it.

I took a lot more photos of (and in) the crowd itself. But here I wanted to show the people who, at least at the beginning of the day, hovered around the fringe of the protest. The people who usually get overlooked. The people who don’t make the highlight reels or the news reports. As so many protest signs said, you know things are grim when even the introverts show up.

You’ll notice that most of these photographs are of women. You’ll notice they’re not drawing attention to themselves. They’re drawing attention to the signs they’re carrying. Signs they mostly made themselves. There’s a song from the 1950s resistance movement in South Africa that goes, “Wathint’ abafazi, wathint’ imbokodo.” This translates as:

When you strike the women, you strike stone.

We’ve been striking stone for decades. Centuries. Eventually, it’s going to spark a fire that will incinerate the patriarchy. It may still be a long time coming, but it’ll happen. And when it does, women like the ones in these photos–the ones quietly occupying space at the fringe–they’ll have helped light that spark.

11 thoughts on “hands off, the fringes

  1. Thanks for this. I’m going to share it. I especially loved the inclusion of the translation of the South African resistance song. In my little town of Red Lodge in the very red state of Montana (sad, it used to be better), we had about 130 people take over all four corners of one of the busiest intersections on our main street. (There’s a small park there. but it couldn’t hold all the people who showed up so we spread out to all the corners.)

    There were definitely more women than men, some older women with canes and one who is on oxygen. All are pissed and yes, we were happy too, just to be together in solidarity. It was encouraging how many honked and gave us thumbs up in support. Of course, there were also a few who rudely let us know they do not approve of our belief that the man for whom they voted is destroying our democracy.

    Sorry… I have no clue what I’m supposed to do with the button to email me new posts. I’m already subscribed to your newsletter so I turned off the email me new posts.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Red Lodge, Montana is about as America as it gets, so it makes me really really happy to hear y’all stood up and raised a little ruckus.

      Some newspaper columnist noted that when app. 3.5% of a population opposes the government, that government usually falls. By all accounts, about 1% of the US population marched or demonstrated on April 5th. We still have a ways to go, but 1% is a pretty big number for the first event.

      And don’t worry about the button thing. I confess, I don’t pay any attention to that stuff. I mainly write these posts for myself, just me sounding my barbaric yawp over the roofs of the world (as Whitman put it); I’m astonished that anybody reads them.

      Like

    • Jody, darlin’, I really needed a day like that. I feel much better today, having seen so many regular folks standing up and making their voices heard.

      Like

  2. Yes, you really know it’s bad when the introverts show up. That’s a true mark.

    Thanks for going around the fringes. Those people will have appreciated being seen even if they didn’t want to make a song and dance about it.

    The woman with 2 signs – epic, both of them. And “We the people, are pissed off!” wonderful. That’s 3 -shirts waiting to be made.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Sue, there was one sign I could never get a good photo of. An older woman wearing a makeshift Handmaid’s Tale outfit, holding a sign saying, “Kim Reynolds is a cunt!” (Kim Reynolds is our MAGA governor.)

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for this! Paul and our boy Riley and his girlfriend went (with a double sided sign I made for them) to the big Seattle gathering, where they estimated 25,000 people gathered- hard to comprehend so many people crammed around the area around the Space Needle. I didn’t go, due to physical limitations of various sorts, and honestly that was the right decision for me. They lost each other several times in the crowds and phone service was completely overwhelmed so it made it very hard to communicate. Lessons learned: establish a place and time to meet up even if you can’t contact them. But like with your place, the mood was good; pissed off but happy.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Love this! What a positive and empowering feeling to be in a crowd of peaceful, witty (the “super” and “stormy daniels” signs!) like-minded strangers. The feelings may only be transitory – for now – but humour and hope are so powerful.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I may be naive, but I don’t think this mood is transitory. I think there are enough genuinely pissed off & frightened people out there that this will continue. At least that’s what I’m hoping.

      Like

  5. Thank you for recording your impressions of this day. I have essentially stopped paying attention to any news but the strictly essential, and I thus saw almost no reporting about the protests. I’m glad to hear that the turnout was better than expected. Makes me want to join the next one.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to greg Cancel reply